Header advertisement
Header advertisement
  • HOME
  • People
  • Blogs
  • OPINION: The Fallacy of Global Poverty Reduction Strategies
Title

OPINION: The Fallacy of Global Poverty Reduction Strategies

FacebookTwitterWhatsAppEmailGoogle+
Morris Komakech
Morris Komakech

    By: admin

  • Feb 13,2017
  • 1758 Viewed

By: Morris Komakech

My friend Ojotre and his fiancee have travelled through many countries in Africa. They have marvelled at the sight of expensive government guzzlers – four-wheel drives – emblazoned with big inscriptions such as “Poverty ‘Eradication’ or ‘Alleviation’ Programs”, and yet everywhere they have visited, unusual forms of poverty confronted them. This couple has wondered as to why African governments extol publicly an onerous task upon which they have no control.

Poverty alleviation is a hoax. Poverty eradication is a myth. One obsession of governments and international donors is this patronage and ruse that they intend to eradicate or alleviate absolute poverty.

Many of these people use that phrase to mean many different things at different levels depending on their role and the powers they hold. Poverty alleviation/eradication could mean exploitation, underdevelopment, political capital, power over (patronage), and imperialism (neoliberalism – emerging markets). There is a whole industry and market out there where poverty is a commodity.

What constitutes poverty is highly perceptional, relative, and political. As a political object, poverty is framed to justify a mobilising ideology; as an international development issue, it is framed to conjure a sense of benevolence and sympathy.

Incidentally, every effort at eradicating poverty only exacerbates it. Every poverty alleviation/eradication attempt has provided temporary fix and perpetuated worse outcomes for the long term, including producing disease and further helplessness/dependency.

To understand poverty, we have to understand what it is not – wealth, abundance, access, equitable society, power, social class privileges, and the manner in which societies and economies are organised and operationalized.

Once we appreciate fully the structural systems that produce, reproduce, and transmit power globally and locally, we then can courageously grapple with poverty as the function of societal inequality resulting from that power relations and its controls production.

Thence, to alleviate poverty one has to focus on the pervasive inequalities in society that deprive people of resources and opportunities.

The antithesis of poverty therefore is providing equal opportunity for production and distribution of resources. People can get out of poverty if they have ownership over their means of production and the products of their labor.

When people have control over their environment and control over the requisite tools to harness and take way over their environment, then they can emerge out of poverty. However, in all these poor countries, the glaring lack of infrastructure to support wealth creation and distribution, as well as the unequal rules of global trades and transnational movements, inextricably bind disadvantaged people to absolute loss of control over production, labor, capital, and environment. Poverty therefore is systemic and structural such that “alleviation” or “eradication” are obscurantist strategies.

There is a common observation that if 10 of the world’s richest were to share half of their wealth with the rest of the world, nearly 3.5 billion people, or half the world’s population would emerge out of absolute poverty. This formula applies in every society where enormous amount of wealth is concentrated in the hands of a small percentage of individuals.

For a meaningful progress in improving life conditions, social and historically entrenched inequalities in this world should be the target of discussion. It is not coincidental that the countries usually designated as endemically poor also share a history of profound repeat abuse – slavery, colonialism, and now corporate imperialism.

For societies where poverty is endemic, you find a history of colonialism, disease, corporate exploitation, ethnic clashes, dictatorships, and environmental degradation.

Poverty therefore is the product of all these entrenched inequalities that we never debate. Poverty has nothing to do with what we invest our time, money, and resources on such as MDGs or SDGs.

We must often revise the nearly prophetic works by Nina Munk, Dambisa Moyo and many other thinkers before and after them who have countered dominant discourses about global anti-poverty strategies.

They called upon the world to recognise the inherent historical factors that subverts real development, address structural bottlenecks – unfair global trading rules, and the destructive economic policies such as structural adjustment that have further underdeveloped states in the southern hemisphere. Structural adjustment policies are never going to eliminate poverty, but produce it!

Header advertisement
# , # , #

Don't miss the stories AND LET'S go!!!

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)
Loading...Loading...
 
Related Articles

OPINION: There is No Crisis of “Succession” in the Country

By: David Mafabi  “People have always been the foolish victims of deception and self-deception in politics, and they will always be until they have learnt

OPINION: Of Rwabwogo’s NRM Redemption Endeavor and Mafabi’s NRM Loyalty Contest

By: Boaz Byayesu Recently, as I was reading these two gentlemen’s pieces in the Ugandan Newspapers including Prof. Kanyeihamba’s relevant bold critique, the no nonsense

Filip Reyntjens: The Hutu Power Ideologue Favourite Expert

By: Tom Ndahiro Academics researchers have had and continue to have significant influence on how Africa is defined. This has been particularly true of Rwanda

OPINION: Mandatory Vehicle Inspection is Unlawful and a Rip-Off

By: Andrew Karamagi On December 9, 2016, a Swiss company, Societe Generale de Surveillance (SGS) held an inauguration ceremony for its first motor vehicle inspection station

A Patriot’s Open Letter to President Museveni – Part II

By: Boaz Byayesu Mr. president, while I thank you so much as we celebrate the registered achievements and accomplishments of your great leadership as enumerated below, I humbly ask you

OPINION: Unraveling Prof Reyntjen’s Rwanda Genocide Spin

By: Tom Ndahiro On 2nd January 2017, Belgian Professor Filip Reyntjens posted a draft paper written with two unnamed “colleagues” on his Facebook page. He

OPINION: Youth Unemployment is a National Security Issue

By: Morris Komakech Over the weekend, I struck a rather interesting conversation with some young people on my Facebook chat. These chats started with usual

OPINION: Waive Taxes on Agriculture Inputs to Develop the Sector

By: Charles Masereka Yoronimu Uganda’s agriculture sector has failed to develop at the annually projected rates, a fact that has kept many away from engaging

A Patriot’s Open Letter to President Yoweri Museveni

By: Boaz Byayesu Mr. President, please accept my sincere thanks for your great leadership derived from your great ideology and the durable purpose sandwiched with

Should You Build or Buy Your Dream House?

By: Rebecca. K. Kamugungunu Owning a home is a big deal for Ugandans and also costly at the same time so owning a home is

Header advertisement
Header advertisement


Error, no group ID set! Check your syntax!
Latest News


Stephen Omony Joins City Oilers on Four Year Deal

Reigning National Basketball League (NBL) champions City Oilers officially confi... (Read More)

2005 – 2017: A Look at Geoffrey Massa’s National Football Career

Raising from the dusty streets of Mbale town, going through the ranks at the con... (Read More)

Speaker Kadaga Flags off 100 Youths to Work in Qatar, UAE Under Middle East Consultants

Speaker of Parliament Rebecca Alitwala Kadaga has Wednesday sent off a group of ... (Read More)

KAWEESI KILLING: Museveni Probes Criminal Mafia Network in Police

President Museveni has authorised a parallel investigation into the assassinatio... (Read More)

Annual Performance: Stanbic Bank Registered Ush 191Bn Profit in 2016

Banking giant Stanbic Uganda has Wednesday announced it’s 2016 performance... (Read More)

Isingiro District Chairman Defies Minister On Quarantine Again

The Isingiro district LC 5 Chairman Jeremiah Birungi Kamurari has once again opp... (Read More)

Named: Finance Ministry Officials Arrested for Taking Bribes from Investors

Identities of the two Finance Ministry officials arrested for soliciting bribes ... (Read More)

UCC Orders Deactivation of All Unregistered Simcards Tonight

Uganda Communications Commission has ordered for the immediate deactivation of a... (Read More)

Uganda Cup: Express Drawn Against URA FC

Record Champion’s Express football club have been pitted against Uganda Revenu... (Read More)

Youth Livelihood Fund Isn’t Presidential Handshake – Youths Warned

The Ibanda Deputy RDC Mary Bashongoka Kamaduka has cautioned the Youth Livelihoo... (Read More)

Politics

Muntu Warns that Uganda Could Degenerate into a Terror Run State

Following the dreadful killing of the former Assistant Inspector General of Poli... (Read More)

 

Error, no group ID set! Check your syntax!
Special Reports

Shocked Ugandan Officials Quit Senegal Amid Morocco, Western Sahara Row

Ugandan Finance and diplomatic officials are returning from Senegal following a ... (Read More)
Travel

French Embassy to Promote Uganda Through French – Cranes Game

The French embassy has revealed plans to fly the French military soccer team to ... (Read More)
Like Us on Facebook
Acquistare Cialis here.