Header advertisement
Header advertisement
Title

OPINION: Mandatory Vehicle Inspection is Unlawful and a Rip-Off

FacebookTwitterWhatsAppEmailGoogle+
Capture

    By: admin

  • Mar 10,2017
  • 2552 Viewed

By: Andrew Karamagi

On December 9, 2016, a Swiss company, Societe Generale de Surveillance (SGS) held an inauguration ceremony for its first motor vehicle inspection station in Kawanda, north of Kampala.

The company has been contracted by the Ministry of Works to conduct mandatory inspections, ostensibly to curb the high rate of accidents and emissions, both of which are apparently caused by vehicles in poor mechanical condition.

My contentions against this scheme revolve around three points:

Abdication of responsibility by public institutions:

In an effort to understand the institutional framework that governs (public and private) transportation, physical infrastructure, licensing, regulation and taxation, I cast my net deep into the sea of the Policies and Laws of Uganda and I found four institutions in my net: in no particular order, I found the Uganda Police Inspector of Vehicles, Customs Department of Uganda Revenue Authority, Uganda National Roads Authority, Uganda National Bureau of Standards as well as the National Road Safety Council. The Traffic and Road Safety Act 1998 as well as the Import Inspection and Clearance Regulations 2015 were also particularly helpful.

Summarily, the aforementioned public bodies are mandated and owe Ugandan taxpayers a duty of care with regard to the durability of public infrastructure (roads and accessories like traffic lights), automobiles on the market, quality of the fuel that cars consume as well as registration and licensing.

Has the Uganda Police Inspector of Vehicles been rendered useless? Have the Uganda National Bureau of Standards and the Customs Department at URA abandoned their roles of ensuring that all imported products are mandatorily inspected and their fitness for purpose established before they get into the market?

If these two haven’t abandoned their statutory duties (see Section 3(e); 3(f) and 43 of the UNBS Act, Chapter 327 of the Laws of Uganda), why should we pay twice for a service that was already provided and paid for by the end-user at the point of purchase?

How will the cash-strapped National Road Safety Council which received a paltry one hundred and fifty million shillings for Financial Year 2014/2015 function when part of its mandate has been outsourced to a private player, SGS?

Incoherent public policy

The argument by then Minister of Works John Byabagambi to the effect that the inspection is being undertaken to curb accidents and emissions is reflective of an acute lack of understanding on the part of those who purport to be in charge of our public affairs.

Because of the prevailing taxation regime, it is easier to buy a used (reconditioned) vehicle in Uganda today than a new car.

Would it not make more sense to reform the tax code with a view to encourage Ugandans to buy new, first hand cars which are safer and more environmentally friendly? Instead, one public institution charges unconscionable tax rates for new cars (thereby forcing buyers to purchase older cars) while another institution punishes them by charging them for mandatory vehicle inspection for buying older and less environmentally friendly cars! These two angles are treated as entirely unrelated. One institution is anxious to hit revenue collections by all means while others are starved of funds and rendered useless.

Misuse of public offices

This is not the first such haphazard scheme insofar as public and private transportation is concerned. Years ago, road users were stampeded into installing seatbelts. Owners of heavy commercial vehicles had to incur an extra cost of purchasing and having a speed governor fitted.

The ostensible reasons of road safety were clouded by the questionable circumstances surrounding the award of this tender and the abrupt conclusion of the exercise. It did not help matters when it was widely rumoured that a businessman had imported container-loads of seatbelts and speed governors and having failed to get market for the consignments, connived with top guns in law enforcement and that as soon as the last seatbelt and speed governor had been sold, the exercise stopped!

Is it any wonder that a random deadline of June 2017 has been set for inspection, after which defaulters shall be heavily penalized?! For argument’s sake, is it possible to inspect all vehicles in Uganda in a period of seven months? Perhaps by this time, the kingpins of this ‘deal’ will have hit their targeted sales.

Was a competitive procurement process followed for this mandatory inspection? Who owns the Ugandan subsidiary of SGS? What are the technical competencies of the people conducting the actual inspections? Are they accredited by car manufacturers? Are they automotive engineers?

You do not need a magnifying glass to see the fingerprints of fraud, collusion and impropriety surrounding what might in all likelihood turn out to be the latest in a series of continuing heists by public officials who connive with private players to fleece Ugandans under the veil of law enforcement.

Before I sign this off, I have a lingering question in my mind around the duty of care that public institutions owe us as citizens and taxpayers. Inspection of any sort is premised on the assumption that the person being inspected should have no excuse for not meeting the set standards. What kind of roads do we have so that our vehicles should be expected to be of a certain standard?

Many Ugandans regularly have to bear the high costs of replacing shock absorbers, bumpers, grills, tyres and rims due to the damage that is sustained from potholes-turned-gulleys and sometimes fishponds; the traffic lights at Jinja Road have been off for five days—and the skid marks and shards of glass on the tarmac are proof of the accidents that this has caused; who is responsible for traffic lights operability? If the electricity bills have not been paid, why should we road users who pay taxes daily be punished for the malfeasance of a public body? Whereas we are obliged to drive on the left hand side of the road in Uganda, it is no longer possible because if you used the Najjeera Road for instance, you would be forced to drive on what is left of the road, not necessarily on the left hand side!

Will inspecting vehicles cure this state-of-affairs?

For these reasons, I am commencing a campaign against this mandatory vehicle inspection and encourage all taxpayers and road users to join me so that we resist this latest episode of extortion and daylight fraud by lazy and incompetent public officials who are in cahoots with disingenuous business interests disguised in the veils of road safety. Relevant public bodies may want to consider successive reports which have listed the leading causes of road accidents as drink-driving, porous licensing processes, unmarked black spots and poorly built roads.

I am happy to donate the inspection charge of 110,000 shillings to paint zebra crossings at the entrances to many primary schools so as to save our children from the speeding convoys of public officials which feature air-suspension systems that shield them from the craters that we have to endure on these cattle paths they call roads.

In the meantime, I’m going to consider a lawsuit with the intention of compelling SGS to refund all car owners who have been fleeced in the name of mandatory inspection.

# , #

Don't miss the stories AND LET'S go!!!

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)
Loading...Loading...
 
  • Oyebare Edson

    Your points are clearly explained, a lawsuit is very urgent to halt the so called inspection.what will happen to an inspected vehicle driven from ishaka to kasese “road” after damaging all shocks.Have joined the campaign

  • Fred Carney Kawere

    True, otherwise why do we need to service vehicles, pay pre-import inspection fees. Why has one to drive over 10km to Kawanda and then pay a hefty 80K, for what? Inspection after registration? why can’t URA inspect the vehicles before we buy them?

  • DavidBuyinza

    Indeed this is robbery in broad daylight!!! Doesn’t make sense at all!! Actually it’s insulting our intelligence!! I’m all in for the campaign to resist this ripoff..

  • Kaka John

    Andrew, you have raised very pertinent issues. This scheme, which is a real reap-off, should be resisted by every resident of Uganda (Ugandan or not), vehicle owners or not, for the following reasons:-
    1. it is unnecessary inconvenience for all vehicle and road users, and will end up increasing the cost of travel as vehicle owners (especially transporters) pass on the cost to their customers.
    2. I have read and hear that from the time the scheme was launched, all motorists have just SIX months to have their vehicles inspected and pass the tests. Otherwise, they will be unroadworthy. But at the moment, 3 months down the road, there are not more than 3 functional inspection units in the country. And all these units are located in Central Uganda. This implies, a motorist in Kisoro, Karamoja, Bibia, Kitgum, Arua, etc has to drive his/her vehicle over long distances on very bumpy road some full of port holes, for inspection. I bet, by the time the vehicle arrives in Central Uganda, it will be with worn out brake pads, broken suspensions and springs, etc. The cost of fuel alone plus the wear and tear, and the lost man hours (useful time that would have been otherwise used for income generation) will be lost.
    3. I am told, the present capacity of inspecting the vehicles may not exceed 100 vehicles per day. Given the current vehicle population of vehicles in Uganda of about 800,000, your guess is as goon as mine when the last of the 800,000 will be inspected, assuming no ‘new’ ones join the road!! So when one drives those long distances, one has to put up with a possibility of sleeping in a lodge or even the vehicle, because the chances of the vehicle not being worked on on arrival are high!!I
    4. It is not only Uganda based vehicles cause accidents on the road (assuming that is the reason for the exercise). So what is going to happen to a multitude of long distance hauliers and trucks that transit through our country??
    5. Come 6 months and hundreds of thousands of vehicles will not have been declared ‘road-worthy’. Has any one posed and though of the mayhem and chaos that will happen to our transport system including PSVs, buses, commodity (foods, etc) trucks – the shortage of food and public transport will surely cause a mega revolt. GEN KAYIHURA, MAY NOT EVEN HAVE THE CAPACITY TO HANDLE IT.

    I could go on and on. But my humble appeal, is that the powers that be reconsider this matter, and have a more rational way of approach to it. Let the centres be multiplied across the country, the fees be reduced, the period be lengthened, the fines be reduced, etc, etc before thinking of even the deadline!! The law society should simply run to courts of law or petition parliament to have the entire scheme stopped,

    I appeal to our parliament and the Rt Hon Speaker, to consider this as a matter of utmost concern, and even launch an investigation into the entire scheme, because capable local agencies do exist, which have now been made redundant. I CAN SMELL A ROTTEN RAT!

Related Articles

OPINION: Of Rwabwogo’s NRM Redemption Endeavor and Mafabi’s NRM Loyalty Contest

By: Boaz Byayesu Recently, as I was reading these two gentlemen’s pieces in the Ugandan Newspapers including Prof. Kanyeihamba’s relevant bold critique, the no nonsense

Filip Reyntjens: The Hutu Power Ideologue Favourite Expert

By: Tom Ndahiro Academics researchers have had and continue to have significant influence on how Africa is defined. This has been particularly true of Rwanda

A Patriot’s Open Letter to President Museveni – Part II

By: Boaz Byayesu Mr. president, while I thank you so much as we celebrate the registered achievements and accomplishments of your great leadership as enumerated below, I humbly ask you

OPINION: Unraveling Prof Reyntjen’s Rwanda Genocide Spin

By: Tom Ndahiro On 2nd January 2017, Belgian Professor Filip Reyntjens posted a draft paper written with two unnamed “colleagues” on his Facebook page. He

OPINION: Youth Unemployment is a National Security Issue

By: Morris Komakech Over the weekend, I struck a rather interesting conversation with some young people on my Facebook chat. These chats started with usual

OPINION: Waive Taxes on Agriculture Inputs to Develop the Sector

By: Charles Masereka Yoronimu Uganda’s agriculture sector has failed to develop at the annually projected rates, a fact that has kept many away from engaging

OPINION: The Fallacy of Global Poverty Reduction Strategies

By: Morris Komakech My friend Ojotre and his fiancee have travelled through many countries in Africa. They have marvelled at the sight of expensive government

A Patriot’s Open Letter to President Yoweri Museveni

By: Boaz Byayesu Mr. President, please accept my sincere thanks for your great leadership derived from your great ideology and the durable purpose sandwiched with

Should You Build or Buy Your Dream House?

By: Rebecca. K. Kamugungunu Owning a home is a big deal for Ugandans and also costly at the same time so owning a home is

Open Letter to President Donald Trump on Climate Change

By Masereka Charles Yoronimu Congratulations His Excellency Donald John Trump, the 45th president of the United States of America upon successful inauguration. A vote of

Header advertisement
Header advertisement

Header advertisement
Error, no group ID set! Check your syntax!
Latest News

Header advertisement

Fury as Pioneer Bus Crashes Woman

Police was called in urgently to calm a rowdy crowd after one of the street vend... (Read More)

FBL: Maroons’ Hopes of Direct Promotion Held Huge Blow

Fufa Big League Kiira United 2-1 Maroons FC Maroons will have to wait for anothe... (Read More)

Lord Mayor Lukwago Skeptical on Museveni Camera Project

Kampala Lord Mayor Erias Lukwago has said he is doubtful the Closed Circuit Tel... (Read More)

Ssekisambu Stars as Vipers Annihilate Kiboga Young

2016/17 Uganda Cup Vipers 7-0 Kiboga Young Uganda Cup holders Vipers Sports Club... (Read More)

Opposition MPs Want Report on Kaweesi Murder in 3 Weeks

Opposition Members of Parliament (MP) led by the Shadow Defense Minister, Gilber... (Read More)

DP Rushes to Constitutional Court Over Opposition Leadership in Parliament

Opposition Democratic Party (DP) National Vice President and EALA MP, Fred Mukas... (Read More)

UPDF Recover 2 Guns, 6 Bombs in Tororo Hospital

By David Oduut The Uganda Peoples’ Defense Forces UPDF has Thursday afternoon ... (Read More)

New Guidelines to Reduce Government Importation

Ministry of Finance has Thursday announced a new set of guidelines aimed at prom... . (Read More)

Debutant Waiswa Scores Late as Uganda Hold Kenya

FIFA international friendly Kenyatta stadium, Machakos Kenya 1-1 Uganda Moses Wa... (Read More)

Kabale: Murder Suspect Arrested at Prisons Recruitment Centre

Benson Andinda Basheija, a 26 year old murder suspect was on Thursday arrested a... (Read More)

Politics

Rugunda Hails ‘Inspirational” Obote Minister Dr Nkwansibwe

The Prime Minister Dr David Livingstone Ruhakana Rugunda paid a moving tribute ... (Read More)

 

Error, no group ID set! Check your syntax!
Special Reports

SPECIAL REPORT: What Makes Uganda Standard Gauge Railway Costly?

Around 2010, East African leaders realised that infrastructural bottlenecks were... . (Read More)
Travel

French Embassy to Promote Uganda Through French – Cranes Game

The French embassy has revealed plans to fly the French military soccer team to ... (Read More)
Like Us on Facebook
Acquistare Cialis here.