Header advertisement
Title

Filip Reyntjens: The Hutu Power Ideologue Favourite Expert

FacebookTwitterWhatsAppEmailGoogle+
Tom Ndahiro
Tom Ndahiro

    By: admin

  • Mar 13,2017
  • 2619 Viewed

By: Tom Ndahiro

Academics researchers have had and continue to have significant influence on how Africa is defined.

This has been particularly true of Rwanda which was little known and of little interest to the media until the 1994 genocide against Tutsi.

After the initial news reports, capturing the shock and horror, the media turned to NGOs and academic researchers whom they perceived as the experts on the hitherto little known country.

And no one has dined out more on this supposed expertise on Rwanda than Belgian professor Filip Reyntjens. His word on Rwanda has been gospel. A generation of students like An Ansoms, who have sat at his feet, reference him religiously, and their own subsequent writing is often little more than a variation on a theme of their mentor’s work.

No programme or documentary on Rwanda is complete until he has pronounced his views on it. It is therefore worth taking a closer look at the basis of this expertise.

In a long paper published in The Journal of Democracy magazine in 2015, Professor Reyntjens groups opinion about Rwanda among those held “by most international aid agencies, and has been voiced by public figures such as Bono, Rick Warren, Bill Clinton, and Tony Blair” who speak admiringly of the RPF, and, “scholars” among whom he naturally counts himself.

Reyntjens dismisses the former as misguided dupes, and invites the reader to trust him and “other scholars.”

But some of the scholars for whom he seeks to speak beg to differ. Jacques Morel, a French academic who has written extensively about the role of France in the Tutsi genocide, says of Filip Reyntjens, “he is a friend of genocidaires … often quoted in the media as an impartial expert”.

“He is famed for having published a book which supposedly identified the missile launchers which brought down the then President of Rwanda, Juvenal Habyarimana’s aeroplane.”

“While most of the facts he [Reyntjens] reports point to Hutu extremists having been responsible, his conclusion blame the Rwanda Patriotic Front (RPF) fighters.”

Morel goes on to state, “doubts about his objectivity are confirmed by his autobiography in which he says that he participated in the drafting of the 1978 Rwanda constitution. He therefore instituted an apartheid regime against part of the population.”

In fact Professor Reyntjens headed the team which drafted the 1978 Rwanda constitution. Professor René Lemarchand, an American academic describes Reyntjens as an “eminent and reliable analyst” of the pre-genocide Rwandan politics and “the most reliable source on post-genocide developments in Rwanda”

Lemarchand and Reyntjens form a mutual admiration society in which one praises the other and roundly attacks any other academic who disagrees with their anti RPF line. But this “most reliable source” on post-genocide Rwanda, has little knowledge, and even less understanding of post genocide Rwanda.

Since 1994, Reyntjens has been in Rwanda for all of one week (15th-22nd October 1994). Even calling him an “eminent and reliable analyst” of pre-genocide Rwanda would be overstating the case.

It is however true to say that his knowledge of Rwanda leading up to the genocide against Tutsi is both extensive and intimate. In November of 1990, a month after the beginning of the war with the RPF, Habyarimana’s government organised two delegations, one for Europe and one for North America.

The purpose of these delegations was to drum up support for the Habyarimana government, and to counter what they called “RPF propaganda.” Professor Reyntjens was part of the delegation to Geneva, representing the Habyarimana government. Hardly the objective scholar he styles himself can stoop that low.

The European delegation, of which Professor Reyntjens was part, was led by none other than Ferdinand Nahimana, an historian who was later described by a witness at the International tribunal for Rwanda (ICTR), as “Rwanda’s Joseph Goebbels.” The leader of the North American group was Leon Mugesera. He is now serving a life sentence for genocide crimes.

Contrary to Reyntjens’ assertion that he is part of some scholarly opinion, he rightly belongs with the framers of the genocide against Tutsi, the likes of Ferdinand Nahimana, and Leon Mugesera.

And for being “most reliable source on post-genocide developments in Rwanda”, that would require objectivity which cannot get past Professor Reyntjens’ seeming pathological hatred of the RPF. And it would require actually being in post genocide Rwanda to conduct research. The most cursory dispassionate observation would be enough to show that Professor Reyntjens has neither of these requirements.



# , # , # , #

Don't miss the stories AND LET'S go!!!

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)
Loading...Loading...
 
Related Articles

OPINION: Of Rwabwogo’s NRM Redemption Endeavor and Mafabi’s NRM Loyalty Contest

By: Boaz Byayesu Recently, as I was reading these two gentlemen’s pieces in the Ugandan Newspapers including Prof. Kanyeihamba’s relevant bold critique, the no nonsense

OPINION: Mandatory Vehicle Inspection is Unlawful and a Rip-Off

By: Andrew Karamagi On December 9, 2016, a Swiss company, Societe Generale de Surveillance (SGS) held an inauguration ceremony for its first motor vehicle inspection station

A Patriot’s Open Letter to President Museveni – Part II

By: Boaz Byayesu Mr. president, while I thank you so much as we celebrate the registered achievements and accomplishments of your great leadership as enumerated below, I humbly ask you

OPINION: Unraveling Prof Reyntjen’s Rwanda Genocide Spin

By: Tom Ndahiro On 2nd January 2017, Belgian Professor Filip Reyntjens posted a draft paper written with two unnamed “colleagues” on his Facebook page. He

OPINION: Youth Unemployment is a National Security Issue

By: Morris Komakech Over the weekend, I struck a rather interesting conversation with some young people on my Facebook chat. These chats started with usual

OPINION: Waive Taxes on Agriculture Inputs to Develop the Sector

By: Charles Masereka Yoronimu Uganda’s agriculture sector has failed to develop at the annually projected rates, a fact that has kept many away from engaging

OPINION: The Fallacy of Global Poverty Reduction Strategies

By: Morris Komakech My friend Ojotre and his fiancee have travelled through many countries in Africa. They have marvelled at the sight of expensive government

A Patriot’s Open Letter to President Yoweri Museveni

By: Boaz Byayesu Mr. President, please accept my sincere thanks for your great leadership derived from your great ideology and the durable purpose sandwiched with

Should You Build or Buy Your Dream House?

By: Rebecca. K. Kamugungunu Owning a home is a big deal for Ugandans and also costly at the same time so owning a home is

Open Letter to President Donald Trump on Climate Change

By Masereka Charles Yoronimu Congratulations His Excellency Donald John Trump, the 45th president of the United States of America upon successful inauguration. A vote of



Header advertisement


Error, no group ID set! Check your syntax!
Latest News

Header advertisement

Fury as Pioneer Bus Crashes Woman

Police was called in urgently to calm a rowdy crowd after one of the street vend... (Read More)

FBL: Maroons’ Hopes of Direct Promotion Held Huge Blow

Fufa Big League Kiira United 2-1 Maroons FC Maroons will have to wait for anothe... (Read More)

Lord Mayor Lukwago Skeptical on Museveni Camera Project

Kampala Lord Mayor Erias Lukwago has said he is doubtful the Closed Circuit Tel... (Read More)

Ssekisambu Stars as Vipers Annihilate Kiboga Young

2016/17 Uganda Cup Vipers 7-0 Kiboga Young Uganda Cup holders Vipers Sports Club... (Read More)

Opposition MPs Want Report on Kaweesi Murder in 3 Weeks

Opposition Members of Parliament (MP) led by the Shadow Defense Minister, Gilber... (Read More)

DP Rushes to Constitutional Court Over Opposition Leadership in Parliament

Opposition Democratic Party (DP) National Vice President and EALA MP, Fred Mukas... (Read More)

UPDF Recover 2 Guns, 6 Bombs in Tororo Hospital

By David Oduut The Uganda Peoples’ Defense Forces UPDF has Thursday afternoon ... (Read More)

New Guidelines to Reduce Government Importation

Ministry of Finance has Thursday announced a new set of guidelines aimed at prom... . (Read More)

Debutant Waiswa Scores Late as Uganda Hold Kenya

FIFA international friendly Kenyatta stadium, Machakos Kenya 1-1 Uganda Moses Wa... (Read More)

Kabale: Murder Suspect Arrested at Prisons Recruitment Centre

Benson Andinda Basheija, a 26 year old murder suspect was on Thursday arrested a... (Read More)

Politics

Rugunda Hails ‘Inspirational” Obote Minister Dr Nkwansibwe

The Prime Minister Dr David Livingstone Ruhakana Rugunda paid a moving tribute ... (Read More)

 

Error, no group ID set! Check your syntax!
Special Reports

SPECIAL REPORT: What Makes Uganda Standard Gauge Railway Costly?

Around 2010, East African leaders realised that infrastructural bottlenecks were... . (Read More)
Travel

French Embassy to Promote Uganda Through French – Cranes Game

The French embassy has revealed plans to fly the French military soccer team to ... (Read More)
Like Us on Facebook
Acquistare Cialis here.
Header advertisement