Header advertisement
Header advertisement
Title

Filip Reyntjens: The Hutu Power Ideologue Favourite Expert

FacebookTwitterWhatsAppEmailGoogle+
Tom Ndahiro
Tom Ndahiro

    By: admin

  • Mar 13,2017
  • 9470 Viewed

By: Tom Ndahiro

Academics researchers have had and continue to have significant influence on how Africa is defined.

This has been particularly true of Rwanda which was little known and of little interest to the media until the 1994 genocide against Tutsi.

After the initial news reports, http://crmsoftwareblog.com/wp-includes/class-wp-customize-widgets.php capturing the shock and horror, http://colombiareports.com/wp-includes/class-walker-page-dropdown.php the media turned to NGOs and academic researchers whom they perceived as the experts on the hitherto little known country.

And no one has dined out more on this supposed expertise on Rwanda than Belgian professor Filip Reyntjens. His word on Rwanda has been gospel. A generation of students like An Ansoms, who have sat at his feet, reference him religiously, and their own subsequent writing is often little more than a variation on a theme of their mentor’s work.

No programme or documentary on Rwanda is complete until he has pronounced his views on it. It is therefore worth taking a closer look at the basis of this expertise.

In a long paper published in The Journal of Democracy magazine in 2015, Professor Reyntjens groups opinion about Rwanda among those held “by most international aid agencies, and has been voiced by public figures such as Bono, Rick Warren, Bill Clinton, and Tony Blair” who speak admiringly of the RPF, and, “scholars” among whom he naturally counts himself.

Reyntjens dismisses the former as misguided dupes, and invites the reader to trust him and “other scholars.”

But some of the scholars for whom he seeks to speak beg to differ. Jacques Morel, a French academic who has written extensively about the role of France in the Tutsi genocide, says of Filip Reyntjens, “he is a friend of genocidaires … often quoted in the media as an impartial expert”.

“He is famed for having published a book which supposedly identified the missile launchers which brought down the then President of Rwanda, Juvenal Habyarimana’s aeroplane.”

“While most of the facts he [Reyntjens] reports point to Hutu extremists having been responsible, his conclusion blame the Rwanda Patriotic Front (RPF) fighters.”

Morel goes on to state, “doubts about his objectivity are confirmed by his autobiography in which he says that he participated in the drafting of the 1978 Rwanda constitution. He therefore instituted an apartheid regime against part of the population.”

In fact Professor Reyntjens headed the team which drafted the 1978 Rwanda constitution. Professor René Lemarchand, an American academic describes Reyntjens as an “eminent and reliable analyst” of the pre-genocide Rwandan politics and “the most reliable source on post-genocide developments in Rwanda”

Lemarchand and Reyntjens form a mutual admiration society in which one praises the other and roundly attacks any other academic who disagrees with their anti RPF line. But this “most reliable source” on post-genocide Rwanda, has little knowledge, and even less understanding of post genocide Rwanda.

Since 1994, Reyntjens has been in Rwanda for all of one week (15th-22nd October 1994). Even calling him an “eminent and reliable analyst” of pre-genocide Rwanda would be overstating the case.

It is however true to say that his knowledge of Rwanda leading up to the genocide against Tutsi is both extensive and intimate. In November of 1990, a month after the beginning of the war with the RPF, Habyarimana’s government organised two delegations, one for Europe and one for North America.

The purpose of these delegations was to drum up support for the Habyarimana government, and to counter what they called “RPF propaganda.” Professor Reyntjens was part of the delegation to Geneva, representing the Habyarimana government. Hardly the objective scholar he styles himself can stoop that low.

The European delegation, of which Professor Reyntjens was part, was led by none other than Ferdinand Nahimana, an historian who was later described by a witness at the International tribunal for Rwanda (ICTR), as “Rwanda’s Joseph Goebbels.” The leader of the North American group was Leon Mugesera. He is now serving a life sentence for genocide crimes.

Contrary to Reyntjens’ assertion that he is part of some scholarly opinion, he rightly belongs with the framers of the genocide against Tutsi, the likes of Ferdinand Nahimana, and Leon Mugesera.

And for being “most reliable source on post-genocide developments in Rwanda”, that would require objectivity which cannot get past Professor Reyntjens’ seeming pathological hatred of the RPF. And it would require actually being in post genocide Rwanda to conduct research. The most cursory dispassionate observation would be enough to show that Professor Reyntjens has neither of these requirements.

Don't miss the stories AND LET'S go!!!

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)
Loading...Loading...
 
Related Articles

OPINION: Treat Hepatitis B with the Seriousness It Deserves

By: Rajjab Kabaale Whereas Uganda has previously been lauded for its successful fight against global epidemics like HIV/AIDs and Ebola, much of the initial costs

Grassroot Organization, Community Empowerment an Ideal Foundation for Aspiring Museveni Successors

By: Boaz Byayesu Community empowerment is better than pompous democracy talk and mightier than the good theoretical ideological literature. Grassroots organization and construction of communal

Earth Day: The Time is Now to Save Planet Earth

By: Masereka Charles Yoronimu Every 22nd day of April of every year, the world joins hands to mark Earth Day, a day designated to demonstrate

OPINION: Why Uganda Might Soon Need an Agency to Regulate Errant Religious Operators

By: Dennis Owachgiu Religion is ordinarily a matter of personal conviction to a deity, and as such shouldn’t necessitate any form of third-party human meddling

OPINION: Applying Common Sense to Politics is an Uncommon Sense of Practice and Good Politics

By: Boaz Byayesu I read Mr. Ofwono Opondo’s article in the Chimpreports of April 11, 2017 addressing Dr. Stella Nyanzi’s dramatic saga, and I was

Rise of Think Tanks: Do Ideas in Uganda Matter?

By: Morrison Rwakakamba Ideas matter. Substance rather than form is supreme. Truth, reasonableness and respect are critical to blooming of enduring ideas.  And for ideas

OPINION: We Need an Honest Conversation about Employment

By: Ronald Bills Agaba Last week, http://curarlaimpotencia.com/wp-content/plugins/jetpack/json-endpoints/class.wpcom-json-api-get-post-counts-v1-1-endpoint.php at our monthly peer to peer conversatio... (Read More)

OPINION: National ID Data Is Used for Verification

By: Pamela Ankunda The Communications Sector UCC has just issued guidelines to all telecom companies in Uganda: Among these, http://ciudad-deporte.com/wp-admin/includes/list-table.php all new SimCards... (Read More)

OPINION: Yes, Some Meaningful Museveni-Besigye Talks Could Re-Set the Country

By: Morris DC Komakech The looming prospect of talks between FDC leaders and the NRM dictatorship is kind of assuring. “Uncle” Muniini Mulera’s “Letter to

Mao Should Face the Heat and Avoid Tribal Sentiments

By: Francis Akorikin  The recent storm in the Democratic Party has exposed the internal leadership challenges affecting Uganda’s oldest party with both sides of the

Header advertisement

Header advertisement
Error, no group ID set! Check your syntax!
Latest News


Water Shortage as Dams, Swamps Dry Up in Teso

A water crisis is imminent in the eastern Teso Sub region which is still reeling... (Read More)

Ibanda: Health Workers Lack Uniform

Medical workers in 14 health facilities in Ibanda were found by researchers, wor... (Read More)

NWSC Nominated for African Utility of the Year Awards

National Water and Sewerage Cooperation (NWSC) has been nominated in the 2017 Af... (Read More)

AU Commission Officials, Foreign Affairs Officials Discuss Domestication of AU Agenda 2063 in Uganda

AU Commission experts, who were visiting Uganda, met with the Ministry of Foreig... (Read More)

Amb. Tibaleka Calls For Investment In Modern Renewable Energy Technologies In Uganda

Uganda’s Ambassador to Germany, Marcel Tibaleka, held a meeting with Mr. Mauro... (Read More)

Uganda Open For Strategic Partners In The Oil Industry – UNOC

Dr. Josephine Wapakhabulo, Chief Executive Officer, Uganda National Oil Company ... (Read More)

Government to Provide Land for UN Logistics Base Expansion

Government of Uganda will provide 20 acres of land in close proximity to the cur... (Read More)

Police Arrest Man Who Assaulted Muhwezi, Mugume Kids

Police say they have in custody, one man believed to have been involved in the a... (Read More)

Museveni Should Sell Cows to Refund Handshake Money – MP

The Buhweju Member of Parliament, Francis Mwijukye has said Parliament should de... . (Read More)

Anger as Government Scraps Off H/C IIs

Kabarole District Leaders are furious over government’s decision to scrap off ... . (Read More)

Politics

UK Ambassador Hails NRM

By Ibrahim Shamiru Byakika The British High Commissioner to Uganda Peter West ha... (Read More)

 

Error, no group ID set! Check your syntax!
Special Reports

EXCLUSIVE: A Patient’s Disheartening Experience with Jubilee Insurance

On April 19, Paul Wanyoto, a city lawyer, was in a jovial mood as he prepared to... . (Read More)
Travel

Qatar Airways to Offer Discounted Flights in Latest Global Sales Campaign

Qatar Airways has rolled out a global campaign to offer amazing discounts to tra... (Read More)
Like Us on Facebook
Acquistare Cialis here.